UPDATE: We have been notified by Gale Carson, communications director par excellence at MLGW, that the utility company’s president Jerry Collins has emailed her that the pole, contrary to the opinion of the neighbors, is not an MLGW project and instead, it belongs (and is to be installed) by the Tennessee Department of Transportation. The good news is that MLGW leadership was so responsive to this question. The bad news is that TDOT’s reputation for being unresponsive is well-deserved, so stay tuned.
There’s a poster child of urban difference that’s been laying on its side in East Memphis for so long no one can even remember when it was put there.
It’s a pole, and while we’re unsure of its purpose, we’ve been told that it is to be installed by Memphis Light, Gas & Water Division, but at this point, for the thousands of people who drive by there every day, the big question is: When? If ever?
The pole has been laying there so long that people in nearby offices can’t even remember when it was delivered, but they estimate it was six months ago. That it is an eyesore at a prominent location in East Memphis only makes us wonder the level of indifference that is found in urban core neighborhoods.
The pole is at Poplar at Brookfield in the little median of grass where Poplar divides into east and west lanes with several restaurants as an island in the middle The billboard looming over the location is reminder enough that Memphis puts little emphasis on the way it looks and that Memphis agencies have complicity in the lackadaisical way that it deals with the execution of public works like this.
We’ve written before about the sloppily patched streets left by MLGW and City of Memphis crews after projects, so maybe we just should accept it as business as usual when it comes to scheduling installation of the pole in a reasonable period of time and instead leave it at a highly visible location for months and months.
Footnote: We’re moving up a comment because it speaks directly to the subject of urban indifference:
As SCM hinted, it is not as if that was a particularly lovely stretch of Poplar before the pole arrived. This is off topic from the pole, but relates to what little value the regional market places on what are seemingly the area’s most valuable properties. For this architect and urban planner, it serves a very physical (and somewhat depressing) reminder of the limitations that handicap our market. Belz demolished a multi-story hotel (The Ridgeway Inn) to make room for a proposed 5-story, 50,000 s.f. office building on what is arguably one of the city’s highest visibility properties on one the regions premier avenues. Instead- citing a weak market- Belz subdivided the property into several retail parcels which resulted in the poorly planned and grossly underutilized developments. This parallels the ”re-development” of the Ridgeway Trace Center. Boyle originally claimed their intention was to build a mixed-use development including office, retail and potentially residential space. Instead, after redesigning the site several times post-approval, the final result was an underutilized strip shopping center in the heart of what some real estate professionals (agents) have the audacity and ignorance to term a “central business district”. With all that in mind, the wayward lighting mast hardly comes as a shock.
By the way, has anyone considered the eyesore and light pollution that such a lighting mast I going to create for adjacent offices and hotels?
And a followup comment to that comment:
The Ridgeway Trace development was done by a firm from Texas, Weingarten – not Boyle. The health of the entire corridor from Riverside to the Fayette County line is of great strategic importance to the health of our surrounding neighborhoods.
Great discussion, everyone.
A good point. Almost as bad as the seemingly permanent port-a-potty on the sidewalk in the upscale section of Peabody? This eyesore is apparently a private individual’s indifference though why the city and the neighborhood tolerate it is as big a mystery.
That pole has been there over a year, at least. I’ve often wondered whose it is and why it’s just laying there!
Speaking of sloppy, how about Poplar right by Whole Foods where the sewer was just repaired?
Call MLGW and ask them what it is and how long it will be on the ground.
On second thought, call code enforcement and get them to contact MLGW to correct the problem.
From: “Jerry Collins”
To: galecarson@comcast.net
Sent: Friday, June 28, 2013 7:16:49 AM
Subject: Re: Urban Indifference: A Horizonal Reminder in East Memphis < Smart City Memphis
This is a pole to be installed by TDOT. It is not part of any City or MLGW project.
Sent from my iPhone
As SCM hinted, it is not as if that was a particularly lovely stretch of Poplar before the pole arrived.
This is off topic from the pole, but relates to what little value the regional market places on what are seemingly the area’s most valuable properties. For this architect and urban planner, it serves a very physical (and somewhat depressing) reminder of the limitations that handicap our market. Belz demolished a multi-story hotel (The Ridgeway Inn) to make room for a proposed 5-story, 50,000 s.f. office building on what is arguably one of the city’s highest visibility properties on one the regions premier avenues. Instead- citing a weak market- Belz subdivided the property into several retail parcels which resulted in the poorly planned and grossly underutilized developments. This parallels the ”re-development” of the Ridgeway Trace Center. Boyle originally claimed their intention was to build a mixed-use development including office, retail and potentially residential space. Instead, after redesigning the site several times post-approval, the final result was an underutilized strip shopping center in the heart of what some real estate professionals (agents) have the audacity and ignorance to term a “central business district”. With all that in mind, the wayward lighting mast hardly comes as a shock.
By the way, has anyone considered the eyesore and light pollution that such a lighting mast I going to create for adjacent offices and hotels?
give it to janis fullilove….
Anonymous 11:30: Well-said and directly on the subject of urban indifference. We’re moving your comment into the post itself, and thanks so much for sharing it with us.
Response to Alonzo Weaver, MLGW VP of Engineering Operations:
Mr. Weaver,
TDOT built a foundation to erect the pole.
PROBLEM: If the pole is erected on the existing foundation, it will block the billboard. (See second picture in the original e-mail.)
SOLUTION: TDOT is to build a new foundation further west to remedy the problem, but the electric feed to the high mast would also have to be relocated to the new location.
RESPONSIBILITY: TDOT is responsible for installing the pole, foundation, cables, and conduit.
The fact still remains it is TDOT’s pole.
——————–
The Ridgeway Trace development was done by a firm from Texas, Weingarten – not Boyle. The health of the entire corridor from Riverside to the Fayette County line is of great strategic importance to the health of our surrounding neighborhoods.
Anon 3:52
Thank you for catching my mistake regarding the developer responsible for the Ridgeway Trace development! You hit the nail on the head where your comment about the health of the entire corridor is concerned. Once you are east Manassas, the Union/Poplar corridor quickly becomes a local execution of Soria’s linear city and as such it is the glue that binds and largely defines surrounding neighborhoods. The management and attention that the corridor receives will either serve to elevate or erode the value and quality of adjoining districts. As the focus of the region’s largest conglomeration of office space, medical facilities, higher education institutions and cultural facilities, this corridor is unparalleled in its importance to our area’s ability to compete on all stages.
…and the highest and best use for an incredibly large parcel of land on this corridor at a major freeway interchange is a strip shopping center. Meanwhile TDOT is placing light masts on the corridor apparently without considering the impact on surrounding uses and views. Yikes.
I had the same misunderstanding about Boyle and Ridgeway Trace. However, it sure would be good if Boyle would try to contribute once in awhile to revitalizing Memphis and redensifying its neighborhoods.
redensifying its neighborhoods…Uh, yeah…with WHO?
Anon 9:47,
…with the same people that have been moving to more urban settings for the past 15 years: empty nesters, young families, young professionals, students and those who find spending excessive amounts of time in car a waste of one’s life.
Drove by there this morning, the light pole is now up. Wonder if this blog made any difference about the situation?